Monday, March 4, 2013

Group 2 Discussion Director--The Second Lesson

 



















Questions:


1."Dying? Not the end of everything. We think it is. But what happens on earth is only the beginning". What was going through your mind when you read this sentence?


2.What do you think about the war?


3.Do you want to go back to someday before in your life?


4.Why the Captain shot Eddie's leg?


5.What do you think about sacrifice?

7 comments:

  1. Connector

    ''Most of Eddie's customers now were women alone with children, their fathers gone to fight. Sometimes the children asked Eddie to lift them over his head, and when Eddie complied, he saw the mothers' sad smiles: He guessed it was the right lift but the wrong pair of arms." After the war start, Eddie's customers are just women and their children. Most fathers go to the war, just left their wives and children. Life for them are difficult. This make me think about one of my grandfather's comrade in arms. My grandpa told me, they live in the same village and they are neighbor. They went to war at same time but the man never come back again. He died, left three children for his wife. The woman should makes money and take care three children at same time. Life for them are difficult. I can remember the old lady who always wearing a black jack and always keep silent. Even thought I was very young, I can't forgot the sad face of the old lady. The war has given her too much hurt. In my opinion, the fastest way to destroy human is the war. We don't need war, and we don't need pain.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Story Mapper --Lei Zhang

    1 where the action begins:
    The heaven scene returns to the hill of battlefield where was the Captain's graveyard.

    2 where the key events happened:
    The key event, the Captain teaches Eddie a lesson, happens in the Captain's graveyard. The Captain recalls himself's story and tells to Eddie.

    3 where the action begins:
    The Captain's graveyard becomes to a beauty of nature hill. The hill looks that it did not happen any war.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Summary

    Eddie start to understand why the captain shot him, and this was his second lesson. Eddie forgives the captain after that and he shakes the captain’s hand. Suddenly the war grounds turn into green, also the captain changed his close to be neat. Eddie asked him if he saved the girl? But he didn’t answer his question.
    Then the chapter takes us back to Ruby Pire, exactly the morning after the accident. Dominguez and Willie were eating for the shop to open again. But by habit, they are wandering when Eddie arrived.

    Key Point:

    1- Eddie second lesson is sacrifice.
    2- Sacrifice is part of life, as the Captain teaches Eddie.
    3- It turned out for Eddie that the Captain had died for him which is the opposite from what he thought.
    4- Now Eddie is able to see the war ground without the war after he shakes the captain hand and forgive him.

    ReplyDelete
  4. P93 aspire: to long, aim, or seek ambitiously; be eagerly desirous, especially for something great or of highvalue (usually followed by to, after, or an infinitive)
    P94 symbolic: serving as a symbol of something
    P95 sapphire: the color of this gem, a deep blue.
    P95 brilliantly: shining brightly; sparkling; glittering; lustrous
    P96 sympathetically: characterized by, proceeding from, exhibiting, or feeling sympathy; sympathizing; compassionate

    ReplyDelete
  5. I like the photo! That's a nice touch.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Answers:
    1. I valued everything which once happened to me and I believe that life is a circle. Death is just another way to start a new life.
    2. War has a great impact to our life. During the war, people would be killed, millions of people would lose home, and children cannot attend to school. Also, it would destroy environmental and harm for the animals. I hate wars.
    3. Sometime I want to go back to six years ago. At that time, I just started my job and learn how to be a good worker. If I can restart time from six years ago, I will drop my job and study aboard first and find a job later. I think I waste my best time to study.
    4. The Captain shot Eddie for saving him. Eddie disordered when he saw a big fire, the Captain shot him in order to take him leaving.
    5. Everyone will sacrifice something for others. For your friends, your family, even strangers. Sacrifice is not a bad thing because it makes you growing and learn something from life.

    ReplyDelete