Thursday, March 28, 2013

Group 2 Discussion Question (the third lesson)

Connector



It's not easy for us to forgive others.  Eddie's father  chose to forgive his friend Mickey. He jumped into the cold water to saved the guy who he wanted to kill before. He forgiven him, even he made a big mistake. I think Eddie's father is right. Everyone can make  mistakes in life. Sometimes, those mistakes hurt us seriously. We feel so anger with them, but things are not always what they seem. Like Mickey, he was coarse, but he was not evil. In our life, there are many problems like this. We should be tolerant.

2 comments:

  1. Summarization—the third lesson

    Summary:
    In order to eliminate contradiction between Eddie and his father, Ruby showed two scenes to Eddie. The first scene is Eddie’s father wanted to kill his friend Mickey, who attempted to rape Eddie’s mother. The second scene is Eddie’s father saved Mickey in sea because Eddie’s father remembered what Mickey did to help his family. Ruby told Eddie that Mickey was drunk and depressed when he was waiting Eddie’s father. In Eddie’s mind, the 56-year-old man, his father, calmly died. However, Ruby told Eddie that his father was frozen to death because her husband’s hospital bed was near his father’s. Moreover, before Eddie’s father died,he was very pain in mental. When Ruby knew Eddie’s family had relationship with Ruby Pier, she felt sad and hoped her husband was never built it. So her heaven is the boxcar dinning room. Ruby taught Eddie that people should learn how to forgive because anger not only will hurt others but also will make you painful. Ruby hoped Eddie could forgive his father. After Eddie knew his father’s stories, he forgiven his father.

    Key points:
    1 Ruby showed Eddie what happened in his father.
    2 Ruby taught Eddie that he needed to forgive his father.
    3 Eddie forgiven his father.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Story Mapper

    Where the action begins:
    The action begins at snowy mountain valley. Eddie talked about his father with Ruby, and Ruby would like to tell something about Eddie's father which Eddie did not know. (p. 133)


    Where the key events happened:
    1. The first key event happened at the north edge of Ruby Pier. Eddie's father saved Mickey who was his father's friend although Mickey did something wrong to Eddie's mother. (p.135)

    2. The second key event happened in hospital. Eddie's father did not speak anything in hospital after he saved Mickey. He did not say anything and kept silence until died. (p. 139)

    3. The third key event happened in the restaurant where was in the snowy valley. Eddie knew something about his father that he did not know before. He forgave his father. (p.144)


    The end:
    For preparing Eddie's funeral, pastor asked Dominguez who was Eddie's friend what Eddie's qualities was, and Dominguez said Eddie love his wife very much. (p.145)

    ReplyDelete